Entravia Editorial · June 18, 2026 · 14 min read
A note from our CEO: The following opinion essay is by Kasey Devine, Founder & CEO of Entravia. It reflects his personal views, not a ranking, comparison, or endorsement by Entravia of any organization mentioned. Originally published June 18, 2026.
There is a peculiar modern superstition which holds that the largest thing is always the best thing. We have applied this logic to governments, to churches, to newspapers, and now, with admirable consistency, to the professional employer organization (PEO). The assumption runs something like this: a PEO with offices in forty-seven states and a platform integration for every conceivable employee-facing system must, by sheer mass, know more about your business than a PEO whose President sits on your state legislature's Commerce Committee and whose Office Manager went to school with your Accountant.
I submit that this assumption is not merely wrong. It is precisely backwards.
Before I proceed, let me offer an honest and collegial concession, for I am not a man who mistakes a personal preference for a prophecy. Large PEOs exist, and not always in spite of themselves. They serve hundreds of thousands of clients. Almost all of those clients are quite happy. Smart people, some of whom are my dear friends and colleagues, run these organizations, and I do not write to impugn them. I admire, respect, celebrate, and appreciate their service to SMBs all over our country. I write only to say that the model which I personally think will win the most lasting loyalty over the next five years is not theirs, despite it having been the most effective course of action to-date. You are all, of course, free to prove me wrong. Print this out as fodder and wave it over my head…it only would benefit small businesses and their employees.
What I have observed, across years of watching this industry with the attention one gives to a slow and instructive argument, is that the PEOs building something truly durable share a single quality: they actually know the person they are serving. Not in the abstract. Not as a market segment or a customer persona. They know what that person worries about at two in the afternoon, what the acronyms on their compliance checklist mean, and why a particular clause in their state's labor code matters more to them than it does to a business three states away.
I see three paths by which a PEO can arrive at this knowledge. The first is industry focus. The second is geographic commitment. The third, which is a culmination of one or both of the first two, is an honest reckoning with how PEO services are sold at all.
There is an old and underappreciated truth that a person who has done a thing understands it in a way that a person who has studied it never quite can. The surgeon who has stood at a bedside at three in the morning knows something about the practice of medicine that does not appear in any textbook. The farmer who has watched a season's work washed away in a night's rain understands risk in a manner that no actuarial table fully captures.
This is the advantage possessed by industry-focused PEOs, of which I will highlight three in no particular order that I've been impressed by to illustrate the point for you, the bystander.
Procare HR, the Minneapolis-based PEO that has built itself entirely around senior care and disability services providers. They are not a generalist who has added a care vertical. They are, by their own account, the only PEO to serve exclusively the providers of home care, skilled nursing, senior housing, assisted living, and disability services. When a senior living operator calls Procare, no one requires educating. The PEO already knows about the turnover, the ACA burden in a care environment, the particular cruelty of thin margins in a labor-intensive industry. That is not a sales advantage. It is something more durable: a service advantage that runs all the way through.
Stitch PEO has a similar thesis, but for independent medical practices. They launched as the first PEO purpose-built for physician groups and their onboarding materials cover HIPAA, OSHA, EMR systems, and clinical license tracking as a matter of course. The service delivery matches the sales conversation. This alignment is, I am sorry to report, considerably rarer than it ought to be.
Then there is Arkenstone Defense, which may represent the purest expression of this principle I have yet encountered. Their PEO product was designed for defense contractors and dual-use companies operating inside the thicket of federal regulation. Their timekeeping is audit-ready and exports into DCAA-aligned accounting systems. Their workforce handling accounts for security clearances. CMMC compliance is treated not as a box to check before an inspection but as an operating condition, the way a careful soldier treats their weapon maintenance. The founder is a former Marine infantry officer who built a unicorn defense technology company before turning their attention to the workforce layer that underlies it all. When a government contractor sits down with this team, they do not begin by explaining what a FAR clause is. That context is already in the room. It was there before they arrived.
What these companies share is not merely knowledge. It is the particular confidence of people who have earned their understanding from the inside. Their people came from the industries they serve. They attend the same events, sit on the same boards, and know the KPIs that matter not because someone handed them a fact sheet before a demo, but because they have inhabited that world long enough to stop thinking about it consciously.
This is a moat. And no amount of organizational restructuring at a national generalist will cross it.
One of my heroes, G.K. Chesterton, once wrote, with his customary inconvenient clarity, that the purpose of an open mind is the same as the purpose of an open mouth: that it may close on something solid. The geographically rooted PEO has closed its mouth on something very solid indeed. It has closed it on a place.
There is a difference, and it is not a small one, between a national PEO that dispatches a representative to stand at a booth at the local Chamber of Commerce breakfast, and a PEO whose entire staff lives within twenty miles of the businesses it serves. The first is a transaction performed at distance that may have once had that heart and soul but has abstracted it. The second is membership in a community, and it confers something that cannot be purchased with a marketing budget.
Syndeo, based in Wichita, became the first and only Kansas-based Certified Professional Employer Organization, a distinction then held by fewer than eighty-five companies in the nation. But the certification is almost decorative beside the more important fact: Syndeo's president became a NAPEO board member and helped shape Kansas PEO legislation from the inside, including the state's PEO Model Act. This is not a company sending a hired man to testify before a committee. This is a citizen using his position to improve the conditions under which his neighbors do business.
PRO Resources, rooted in Detroit Lakes, Minnesota since 1991, was grown from a small Midwestern community and has never forgotten where it came from. Their clients are not accounts. They are neighbors. When something goes wrong on a Friday afternoon, the person who answers is not a voice from a call center in a city that cannot find Detroit Lakes on a map. It may well be someone who coached the same hockey team.
IronRoad in Cincinnati has organized its entire culture around servant leadership, which is a fine phrase that means, in practice, showing up in the community as a neighbor rather than as a vendor. Their people volunteer at local organizations that serve families in need. This is not a public relations exercise. This is simply how they operate.
SustainableHR in Madison, Wisconsin did not decide to serve their community. They were already serving it. The PEO formalization came later, as the natural conclusion of years spent working alongside the nonprofits and small businesses of their own city. The sequence matters enormously. It is the difference between a man who moves to a neighborhood to open a shop and a man who opens a shop because he already knows the neighborhood.
What these geographically anchored PEOs offer their clients is the one thing a national competitor cannot manufacture: the credibility that comes from shared experience. When a local PEO offers a reference, that reference is a person you may encounter at the school pick-up line or the farmers' market. That is a fundamentally different weight of testimony. And the advice given by a PEO team that understands not merely the letter of a state's labor code but the actual texture of how commerce is conducted in that place carries a kind of authority that generic counsel, however competent, cannot replicate.
The third path to winning is less romantic but no less important, and it requires a certain courage: the courage to admit that the way PEO services have traditionally been sold may no longer work very well.
The conventional model that built our industry places upon the contemporary single W-2 employee an impossible burden. They are expected to find their own prospects from nothing, build relationships from scratch, navigate a complicated sale, close the contract, manage the transition, and then remain sufficiently involved in the ongoing service relationship to generate referrals and renewals. This is not one job. It is five jobs wearing a single job's clothes, and the wonder (from my perspective) is not that it so often fails but that it ever succeeds anymore.
Certain forward-facing PEO operators are doing something qualitatively different. They are building distribution around referral partners: benefits brokers, accountants, advisors, independent consultants who already possess the trust of the exact client the PEO wishes to serve. The lead arrives already persuaded that the PEO is worth speaking to. The internal representative's role becomes closing and implementation, which are disciplines that can be taught and refined, rather than cold prospecting, which depends too heavily on personality and luck.
This is not a novel idea. The industries that preceded and shaped the PEO industry, financial services and insurance, have understood it for generations. But the PEO industry has clung, with a stubbornness that would be admirable in a different context, to the notion that the W-2 rep you can monitor and control is preferable to the independent partner who may serve several masters but arrives with established relationships that no amount of cold calling can replicate.
The broader shift toward fractional and 1099 arrangements is not a PEO story. It is the story of professional services in our time. The advisors and brokers who work with small and mid-sized businesses are increasingly operating independently, and they have become the most trusted introduction a PEO can receive. The organizations that build genuine partnership programs around them will reach markets that traditional salesforces simply cannot enter efficiently.
This model is also, it should be noted, the natural companion of specialization, or at least the concession to opening a door to it. If your referral partners already inhabit the same industry vertical or community you serve, the clients they send you do not merely trust the introduction. They arrive already inclined to believe that your organization understands their particular difficulties. The two advantages compound each other in the way that good advantages tend to.
The PEOs that will win over the next five years are those for whom specialization and service is not a strategy but a character. It determines who they hire, how they train, what they build, who they promote, and what knowledge is considered worth preserving. If you stand for everyone, you stand for no one. This is not a complicated observation, but it is one that a surprising number of organizations manage to ignore.
When a PEO embeds its commitment to a specific industry or community in every layer of its operation, the flywheel begins its work. Deep trust produces referenceable clients who already know one another. Those references produce more wins in the same niche. The niche deepens the specialization. The specialization deepens the trust. This is not a marketing advantage. It is a durable business.
Now I must say something uncomfortable, because comfort has never been the primary obligation of the honest observer.
I have watched, with the melancholy of a man who had hoped for better, as some PEOs constructed specialization strategies that stopped precisely at the boundary of the sales and marketing department. The sales representative attended the correct conference and offices or lives in the correct ZIP code. The pitch deck deployed the right vocabulary. The proposal mentioned the client's industry by name. And then the client signed, and was delivered to the same generic service team that manages everyone else (increasingly now, with overlooked irony, overseas).
This broken promise is worse than no promise at all. It establishes an expectation and then fails it, and in a business built on trust and referral, the network has a long memory that impacts the entire industry.
There is a deeper paradox worth naming here, and I say this not to wound anyone but because I think it matters. The more successful a PEO becomes, the more vigilant it must be against losing the very qualities that made it successful in the first place. That vigilance is a choice, and it must be made deliberately, repeatedly, and at every level of the organization. To become large, shed your specialization, and also refuse to work with the trusted advisors and referral partners who serve your prospective clients in their local or distributed communities, or doing so merely reluctantly or with suspicion, is not merely a strategic error. It is a kind of blasé hypocrisy. If you were granted the privilege of having ascended to success because of a community, you now perpetually have the duty to extend a hand to and raise your voice for those who built the staircase.
I want to be clear that this outcome is not inevitable. Size does not require it. I am not calling anyone irredeemable, or even referencing any one company. I am rather refocusing us on the small business and the communities they serve, because that is, as I understand it, why we are all here.
If you are a business owner presently weighing your options among PEOs, the question you should ask earliest in the process is this: does this organization understand my world, or am I about to pay for their education in it?
There are more than five hundred PEOs operating in the United States, collectively serving over two hundred thousand businesses employing millions of people. The evidence that PEO partnerships improve business outcomes is substantial. But not all PEOs produce those outcomes with equal reliability.
Ask whether the person selling to you came from your industry or merely researched it. Ask whether the service team has worked with organizations genuinely like yours. Ask how they found you, and if the answer involves a broker or advisor who already knows your business, regard that as a promising sign regardless of size or specialization. Ask for references from clients who resemble you in industry, size, and geography, and ask those clients whether their PEO feels like a vendor or a partner.
The answer, I assure you, will be instructive.
The PEO industry is subject to the same forces that are reshaping every professional services sector: the commoditization of routine work, the consolidation of scale at the top, and the rising expectations of clients who have more choices and more information than their predecessors.
In such an environment, the question is not who possesses the most sophisticated platform or the deepest reserves of capital. It is who has earned the right to be considered irreplaceable.
The PEOs that deeply understand their customers, whether through years of immersion in a specific industry, through genuine membership in a specific community, or through the construction of a distribution model that places the right partners in front of the right buyers, are building something that money alone cannot replicate.
That is where I would place my bet for the next five years. And if you are running a different kind of PEO and you are winning, I mean this in the most sincere and collegial spirit possible: go prove me wrong.
Kasey Devine is Founder and CEO of Entravia.
Disclosure: Of the seven PEOs mentioned in this piece, none are a paying customer of my company. I was not compensated to write this piece, nor was I paid to feature any of the organizations named in it. These are simply the ones that came to mind upon writing. The views expressed are my own.
Bring the deal you've been avoiding. We'll show you how Entravia handles it.